Disability Awareness in Action, 1999
All rights reserved
Written by Rachel Hurst
Designed and edited by Richard Light,
Published by Disability Awareness in Action.
This is a training manual for organisations of disabled people, as guidance for seminars with the media on disability as a rights issue.
The media coverage of disability is one of the main obstacles to disability rights being given the priority they deserve. In every country in the world the media either ignores the rights of disabled people or portrays disabled people as pathetic recipients of charity or tragic but brave victims. The struggle for equality and freedom from oppression and discrimination, which is the real story of the disability movement, is given little space on radio, TV or the print media.
In 1998 Index on Censorship (a UK organisation promoting freedom of speech), the BBC World Service Education and DAA formed an alliance to gain funding for a programme of activities to raise awareness of disability as a rights issue in Africa. In January 1998, Index on Censorship produced a report on the situation of Disabled Africans and in April and May 1998, the BBC World Service produced a series of programmes in the six main languages of Africa (English, French, Portuguese, Hausa, Somali and Swahili) on disability as a human rights issue. A resource kit produced by DM supported these programmes. Then in October, 1998 a three-day seminar was held in Harare, Zimbabwe to bring together disabled and media delegates from all over English speaking Africa to share experiences and to work out a way for using the media to get the human rights message across.
This training manual is based on the experience of that seminar - learning from the successes and the failures of that event - and the training and experience of the writers as educators and trainers. We hope this manual will be used by the disability organisations whose delegates attended the seminar and encourage them to arrange similar seminars in their country and region. We also hope that it will encourage other readers to support similar events in their own countries, across the world.
There is a serious need for disabled activists to be able to use the media effectively - and for the media to understand disabled activists and our issues are as important and newsworthy as any other. We have to learn to make friends with the written word, the camera and the microphone so that we can make our message heard. The media needs us as much as we need them - they need our stories to fill their news-slots!
As well as the suggested programme for a seminar on media and disability rights, we have given organisational guidance and tips for trainers and workshop leaders which should prove useful for any training seminar or workshop that organisations may wish to run on any other subject.
The DAA Resource Kit 1 - How to Work with the Media, would be helpful when used alongside this training manual.
These plans and guidance are for you to use as you wish. They are not rules that you have to abide by, but are an aid your own creativity in making a three-day event an exciting learning experience for all concerned.
Good training is stimulating and enjoyable
This manual should help that enjoyment by assisting you to make sure that you have:
Objectives
You have to be absolutely clear about your objectives and ensure that you communicate them clearly and accurately to everyone concerned. Make them short and focussed. You cannot do everything in one seminar! Repeat them as often as you can - on funding applications, invitations, press releases, reports, programmes, anything and everything you send out regarding this training.
For the Harare Seminar our objective was: to raise awareness of disability as a human rights issue and to work with the media on how to get that message across.
As the objective is to work with the media, then the next task is to build a relationship with our media. You may already have contacts. Strengthen them, invite one or two to a planning meeting to help with technical advice
The seminar in Harare would not have been successful if we had not established a good partnership with the BBC World Service and other media people in Zimbabwe. The journalists felt that it was just as important for them to be part of the seminar as it was for the disabled delegates.
Journalists may be unable to participate in more than one day of a seminar but input from a variety of media people will widen your audience as well as give you a greater breadth of experience.
Helpful hints!
Make friendly contacts with journalists. If you or your organisation is invited to a reception, contact the press officer, who will be an ex-journalist who may be able to help you and suggest other useful contacts.
This is everyone's nightmare - but it has to be overcome if you want to have a good seminar. If you have clear objectives and have already built up a partnership with the media, then you are halfway to having a very good funding application. Building on the success of one seminar, your media friends may well be able to suggest new funding opportunities in your region/country.
Your organisation may have considerable experience in raising money but further information is given in DM's Funding Resource Kit, available from the DM office in London.
Helpful hints!
Try local businesses for sponsorship - they might be more enthusiastic about supporting projects involving the media.
Good Luck !
The programme should allow participants to:
The programme for the Harare seminar lasted three days. We have divided the work into sessions so that you can arrange your own programme over whatever period you wish. Experience in Harare showed that clearly stating the aims for each session helped delegates to get the most from each session. We have suggested timings for each session.
Remember that people cannot learn efficiently for long periods. Educational psychologists suggest that 45 minutes is the maximum period over which most people can remain focused and fully involved. Where the session includes smaller work-groups, the sessions can be extended but, in any event, 90 minutes should be the longest trainees are expected to work without a break.
If there is sign language or other translation with only one translator, you will need to ask the interpreter how often they will need a break (probably every 45 minutes).
Opening Ceremony
15 minutes
This is not compulsory but it will raise the profile of your seminar and give you further media contacts.
A well-known personality or the head of your national TV or radio network, could open the event - this is likely to attract more attention from the media.
Ask the opening speaker to stay for the introductions and discussion of objectives if possible.
Session 1
The aims for this session are:
Suggested method:
15 minutes
Introductions and short discussion on objectives and programme.
25 minutes
Split into small groups and discuss problems that individuals/organisations have had with the media in either their presentation or disregard of disability rights stories.
30 minutes
Bring that back to the full group with highlights from each group with full discussion on how the problems arose and what is the possible solution.
(5 minutes are allowed for the change from groups to plenary and back again)
Session 2
The aim of this session is for delegates to:
Suggested method:
1 hour
Split into groups again and look at positive images in the media. These can be positive images of disability or any other human rights issue.
Feed back to whole group and discussion on what are the shared elements of these positive images - how did the journalists make them into positive, rather than negative images?
Session 3
The aims of this session are:
Suggested method:
30 minutes
Discussion on how to get the message across. Brief overview of the five Ws and an H. (Who, What, When, minutes Where, Why and How - all questions that should be answered in any message giving.)
30 minutes
Individuals write their own story in 100 words trying to answer all those questions as clearly and excitingly as possible.
15 minutes
Two willing volunteers chosen to read out their stories and accept comment from the rest.
15 minutes
Discussion of what is to happen in the next two sessions, which will be practice interviews on TV and radio. Delegates asked to think overnight of stories they want to tell in interviews.
Sessions 4 and 5
The aim of these sessions is to:
Suggested method:
Each session should last 2.5 hours with a 15 minute break
Practical session in TV and radio studios to simulate real studio and interview conditions.
The delegates should be divided into two groups, the first group does TV and the second group radio for Session 4. They change round for Session 5.
Each group will have an introduction from their trainer giving general points for the most effective ways of getting the message across. Then each individual should take it in turns to be both interviewer and interviewee and comments given from the group on performance.
Technical requirements for these sessions:
Session 6
The aim of this session is to:
Suggested method:
20 minutes
Choose a journalist to talk to the group about what they think:
1. are the difficulties in understanding disability as a human rights issue, and
2. are the best ways of building co-operation between the disability movement and the media.
40 minutes
Questions and discussion
1 hour
Full feedback from all delegates and trainers and any observing media people on what they have learnt. It might be helpful to have warned everyone at the end of Session 5 that they will have to do this so that they can think about it and perhaps make some notes.
Session 7
Aims of this session are to ensure that:
Suggested method:
45 minutes
Delegates who have been so active for three days need to apply that sense of purpose to something practical. An action plan, which actually requires individuals to take some responsibility within a set timeframe, is helpful (Appendix 1 gives the Statement and Action plan of the Harare seminar). For Harare it was a requirement of the invitation to delegates that they would take responsibility for putting on similar seminars in their own countries or regions, creating an ever increasing circle of activity to focus on this important issue.
15 minutes
Leave time for saying thank you's and good-bye's. Remind delegates to complete the monitoring forms and leave them with you before they leave (rather than forgetting to post them!).
There are many other things that you can do to become more skilful when 'puffing the message across' on TV or radio:
This is an intensive three-days in which everyone should have the opportunity to participate on an equal basis. It is very difficult to ensure that this happens with too many delegates taking part - even when you divide the delegates into smaller workshops. For the Harare Seminar, we agreed 15-20 delegates - which was a manageable number - and suggest that you limit the people at your seminars to a similar number. Quite apart from the need to ensure that all delegates participate on an equal basis, greater numbers will cause difficulties for the trainers.
It is important that there should be a good gender balance among the delegates. We managed to achieve this in Harare by asking organisations to make a special effort to send women delegates. It is also important that people with different impairments are able to participate.
Helpful hints!
- not to speak too fast if there is a need for interpretation
- that printed material needs to be available in other formats, for example Braille or large print.
Comfortable, accessible meeting rooms and accommodation are essential factors for a good learning/working environment. It is also important that delegates do not get tired travelling from one place to another and are able to go to their rooms for rest, if necessary.
Helpful hints!
If:
then you will have given the delegates and the media present the best possible environment in which to take up the opportunities of sharing experience and seeking solutions to problems.
Below is a list of administrative tasks that are involved in organising a seminar, once funding has been promised, the date and programme has been set and initial contacts with press have been made.
There may be other tasks that you will need to add-these are only for guidance
Pre-seminar - at least 6 months (preferably 9 months)-before date of seminar
At least 2 - 3 months before:
1-week before
After the Seminar
Harare human rights & Media Seminar
Disabled people's organisations must take action to put our message across and the delegates of this seminar will take the following actions:Plan of Action
At all times the message is - Disability is a human rights issue. Our rights are violated systematically, daily in all countries of Africa and the rest of the world. Our message is ignored or distorted by the media. Our humanity is not recognised or recorded.
Work with their organisations to: replicate this workshop in their countries and throughout their region
We have the right to be seen and heard!
The material presented in this Appendix has been taken from DAA's Resource Kit 4: Organisation Building (the full Resource Kit can be obtained from DAA).
Training
Training the membership is one of the most important roles of an organisation. It contributes to the development of individuals and to the democracy and development of the whole organisation. People are the central resource of any organisation. You can make that resource grow by recruiting new members and by increasing the skills and participation of existing members.
Training isn't always formal, through workshops or courses. It can happen through involvement in any aspect of a project.
An important decision for formal training is who is to be trained. Is training an individual better than training a whole group? Who will benefit?
Knowledge is power, but power must be shared.
How things are done may be more important than what is done. Trainer's check list:
Assessment and action
You should be clear on these things before you commit resources to training. Answers to improving an organisation's efficiency may lie elsewhere. You also need to distinguish between present and future training needs. Current needs are due to things not working well at the moment. To solve these problems, change will be needed. Future needs will arise as a result of change.
Training should be directed towards a specific goal. It should involve full participation by trainees and regular reviews of how well the training is working.
Training in groups allows the people taking part to look at themselves and how they work as individuals and as part of a group.
Always include time for evaluation of how a particular training session has worked, what the results were, what the trainees thought of the training and what they got out of it.
Learning from mistakes
Whenever something has clearly gone wrong, rather than giving blame to individuals, encourage everyone to look at the structures of the organisation and what has gone wrong.
Example 1
Perhaps Member A always offers to do something and then doesn't manage it. Don't be cross with Member A. Look at structures for change. Give the work to Member A to share with Member B, who is more likely to do it. It may be that Member A wants to do the work but does not know how to do it and needs help.
Example 2
Member C and Member D always argue in committee meetings and contradict each other. Don't just shout at them but insist that all speakers should talk to the Chairperson, in the order the Chair chooses. The Chair can control who speaks when and can stop arguments developing.
Training model
can lead to
can lead to
can lead to
Involving everyone
Make sure that just a few individuals do not dominate the discussion. It might be useful to report back the main points made in the workshop or seminar, without the need to identify which particular individuals made which points.
It is important to consider the most supportive and relaxing environment for disabled people to develop their ideas and their confidence. It is good for people to develop public-speaking or presentation skills, as this will boost their self-esteem, but at times it can also be useful to break off into small groups for support and discussion.
A good way for a workshop leader to start is to identify the main areas of debate. It is very important that everyone takes part. There will often be one or two people with a lot to say. The leader needs to make sure these people don't dominate and to open the discussion up to others. Often, the quieter people, who are listening carefully to all that is being said, will have as valuable points to contribute as the people who come to the workshop with a lot to say.
Complaints
Common complaints from seminar and workshop participants are that too much time is taken up by lectures from guest speakers or facilitators. A good seminar or workshop will have a brief introduction from the person leading the session and then will move on to group discussion, guided and prompted to some extent by the leader. Too many workshops are run like seminars.
You need to strike a balance. When a seminar is organised to convey new ideas, some participants will complain about a lack of opportunity for individuals to exchange opinions and experiences. Yet, when a workshop is organised to allow for this exchange, some will feel that there is a lack of new ideas.
Remember that some people need more time than others to express themselves. Give space to everybody who wants to make a point or comment. Make sure that everyone understands that they must be patient and must express themselves slowly, so that Sign Language interpreters can keep up.
Teamwork takes planning!
You might want to run through these ground rules before starting a workshop or seminar session:
The inverted pyramid
Writing Clearly in English
Use Examples, Familiar Words, Strong Verbs, and Don't Stop Explaining!
These are excerpts from papers presented by Kit Wells, Trainer. If you copy this material please ensure that Kit well's is credited with the copyright.
The first enquiry or whoever answers the phone
On the spot
Some useful phrases:
"Too early to say exactly what has happened we are doing everything we can to find out what the problem is."
"We will give you a full update in 10 minutes/30 minutes," etc.
"We are doing everything we can to sort it out."
"The company will do everything it can to establish what happened."
Press releases
Whether they are directly involved in the writing of press releases, or more simply responsible for authorising their content and regularity, delegates must remember the following:
Press conferences
Press conferences can be the most effective way of taking charge of events and controlling information to the public. Delegates should bear in mind the following:
How to give a good interview
No instant miracles here, I am afraid-but a few hints and tips to help you.
Improving media awareness within your organisation
Improve media awareness by:
Types of story
Does getting news coverage matter?
Yes!
No!
Name of organisation
Seminar evalutation form
We would be most grateful if you could answer the following questions so that we can properly evaluate the success of this seminar.
Please indicate on a scale of 1 to 5 (where 1 is least value and 5 is very useful and A is absent) the value to you of the following sessions:
Session 1 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | A |
Session 2 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | A |
Session 3 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | A |
Session 4 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | A |
Session 5 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | A |
Session 6 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | A |
Session 7 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | A |
Using the same scale (where 1 is unsatisfactory and 5 is satisfactory, A is absent) please answer the following questions:
How would you rate the venue and its facilities? | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | A |
How would you rate the catering arrangements? | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | A |
How would you rate the general organisation of the seminar? | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | A |
Any other comments that you have:
Please write your name and address if you wish to be placed on the mailing list to receive details of future seminars and conferences:
Name:
Organisation:
Address:
Please hand your completed form to a staff member or place it in the box provided at the registration desk. Alternatively send it to _______at the address below.
ISBN NO: 1 89037 31 0
Printed by:
Freeways
5 Canham Mews
Canham Road
London W3 7SR
United Kingdom
If you wish to duplicate and disseminate any part of this training manual, please credit DAA.
This publication is available in ordinary and large print, on audio tape, in ASCII on computer disc and in English Braille.
Throughout this manual, when DAA refers to 'disabled people' we include people with sensory, intellectual and physical impairments and people with mental health difficulties.
DAA publications are funded through the generosity of ICCO, Comic Relief, CAFOD, and the UK National Lottery Charities Board.